International

 

John Davis

John Davis

Posted July 21, 2010

Published in International

  • digg
  • Delicious
  • Furl
  • reddit
  • blinklist
  • Technorati
  • stumbleupon

Are you a positive or a negative veg*n?

Get VegSource Alerts Get VegSource Alerts

First Name

Email

Email This Story to a Friend




If we ask meat-eaters what they think 'vegetarian' means, most would probably say 'someone who does not eat meat' - but that is not at all how I see it.

I'm a positive veg*n, I eat plant foods. I define myself by what I do, not by the negative of what I do not do. If we define ourselves as a negative of others, then we are saying that they are 'normal', and we are abnormal for abstaining.

When I was in Indonesia last year I went on a great day-trip with a bus full of veg*ns from all over Asia. The driver didn't know my name and at one point referred to me as 'the European guy', which was fine - he could have called me the 'non-Asian guy' as I was the only one, but that would have been odd, maybe even slightly offensive. So why do veg*ns collaborate with the flesh-eaters in defining ourselves as 'non-meat-eaters'.

I do not 'abstain'. I do not 'avoid'.  I am not 'meatless' or 'meat-free'. I simply make a positive choice to eat, and to wear, the things I prefer, and my health, the animals, and the planet, all benefit from that choice.

 

george[the photo right is George Jacobs, chair of the IVU Council, with a friend in Dresden, Germany, 2008]

 

 

By way of comparison, when I was growing up in the 1950s and 60s most people smoked tobacco. They branded me as a 'non-smoker' but I didn't see it way, I just thought it was disgusting and unhealthy , and I certainly did not consider my preference for clean air to be some sort of self-denial.

So when I was offered a cigarette I asked them why they did it - but  they couldn't defend it of course, as the real reason they smoked was just because everyone else did, and they thought it looked 'cool' - encouraged by film star images and mass advertising. 

I like the graphic below as a representation of the image and the reflected reality as I always saw it (courtesy of www.smokingadverts.com )

smoking

 

 

 

 

 

 

Even in the 1980s I had to fight to get a ban on smoking in the office where I was based. One otherwise intelligent colleague couldn't believe that we did not allow anyone to smoke in our house, and tried to brand me as anti-social for that!

In July 2007 the British government finally caught up with some other parts of the world and banned smoking in all public places. So now I'm finally vindicated as the normal one, and the smokers have to stand outside in the rain to indulge their perversion.

I can also remember Frank Sinatra singing about 'one for the road' - but now drinking and driving is universally considered a social evil. So things can change. Maybe one day we'll get to the point where flesh-eating is seen as the abnormality that it is - meanwhile we can at least set a better example of how we define ourselves.

Ultimately we should be aiming to abolish words like 'vegetarian' and 'vegan' completely - normality does not need a label, it's the flesh-eaters who should be branded as abnormal. And in the long term we do not want green labels on supermarket products saying 'suitable for vegetarians' - we want blood-red labels indianon anything which is non-veg. The Indian government tried to do exactly that, but they kept the green, and against predictable opposition the red one got diluted to brown, but at least they do have both (see right).  That will take time for the rest us of course, so for now we have to live with the reality of being a minority, but the way we use language can help towards those long term aims.

So I am not  'non-Asian', I am European.
I am not a 'non-smoker', I am someone who demands the right to breathe clean air.
- and I am not a 'non-meat-eater', I am someone who chooses plant foods, which is what 'vegetarian' originally meant.

The International Vegetarian Union obviously does not have the power to define words, that's just down to common usage, and dictionaries trying to keep up as they change. But we can decide how we define our own membership (groups only, IVU does not have individual members), and we can set a better example.


The above was written in July 2010. In May 2011 it was proposed to make our definition positive and to return it nearer to the original. The proposal was:

"IVU defines vegetarianism as a diet of foods derived from plants, with or without eggs, dairy products, and/or honey."

The last clause being an inevitable compromise. This was to replace the old negative definition:

"For the purpose of membership of IVU, vegetarianism includes veganism and is defined as the practice of not eating meat, poultry or fish or their by-products, with or without the use of dairy products or eggs."

Making the change required a ballot of all 120 IVU member organizations around the world, and as many of those have thousands of individual members who were also consulted. The proposal was supported in May 2011 with a 95% majority.


Later update: Further to the point below about fungi/algae etc - I think most ordinary people would describe a 'plant' as something that grows in the ground and cannot move around of its own accord. Sounds like a mushroom to me... the fact that academic biologists have recently deemed that fungi and no longer in the kingdom of plantae is not going to stop supermarkets selling mushrooms in the fruit and veg section.

wikipedia: "Herbivores are organisms that eat plants." - seems simple enough - would anyone really define a herbivore as a 'non-carnivore', or 'an animal that doesn't eat meat' - with a long list of things excluded from their diet?


For vegan history, see my free e-book: ‘World Veganism – past, present and future.” You can download it for free, or replace your existing copy at: www.ivu.org/history/Vegan_History.pdf (6mb)

IVU on Facebook: www.facebook.com/InternationalVegUnion


FACEBOOK COMMENTS:


12 Comments | Leave a comment

user-pic

Very well said, John. Good food for thought.

user-pic

This is a wonderful concept but let me play Devil's Advocate. Please now, be truthful. You only eat plants? Mushrooms are not a plant. Spirulina is not a plant. Not even dulse or "sea vegetables" are really botanical plants. And salt? Nope, salt is not a plant.

user-pic

Funny you should write this article. This past June, the Denver post published an article focused on Joel Fuhrman's "Nutritarian" concept, but they led off with a statement that vegetarians are defined by what they don't eat. Gah! They only allow 150 word letters to the editor so I responded as best I could. Below is my response which was published in the June 10th edition. Best regards.

Re: “Nutrition ambition fuels a new appetite,” June 7 fitness article.
It was nice to see the article about eating a nutrient-dense diet, the “nutritarian” diet. But why would the author lead the story with the statement that “Vegetarians are defined by what they shun — meat”? It seems pretty obvious that vegetarians are defined by what they do eat — a plant-centered diet.
It is true that many people do not adopt a vegetarian or vegan diet because both are perceived as diets of rejection and denial. Who wants to live a life of denial, especially regarding something as rewarding as eating delicious food? Not many people, including vegetarians. The reason so many people, about 6 percent us, can sustain as longtime vegetarians is not because they are disciplined and willing to suffer for the animals, for the environment or for good health. They endure as vegetarians because, in addition to benefitting the animals, the environment and their own health, they understand that a plant-centered diet is a diet of abundance, of variety and of deliciousness.
Steve Billig, Denver
The writer is director of the Vegetarian Nutrition Center of Colorado.
This letter was published in the June 10 edition.

user-pic

fair comment daisy, though there is perhaps a difference in the botanists' 'plantae' and the way us common folks use 'plant' - and even the botanists only separated fungi from plantae as recently as 1969...

However, as the potential for nit-picking could result in an almost endless list of 'optional extras' - maybe for the definition we should revert to the commonly used 'plant based diet' which implies things other than plants on top of the base.

Some of us were concerned that it could also allow any type of animal product above the base, but we need to keep the IVU definition concise, even if the result is deliberately a little ambiguous.

user-pic

Just giving you a hard time! Anyway I really appreciate the part about normalcy. I see that quite often. For instance, there is "milk" and then there is "breastmilk." Since all milk is breastmilk, and originally human breastmilk, why does cow breastmilk get the "normal" term? As well as with "organic" foods, when organic foods are the original food, the default! With my own garden sometimes I have to remind myself that this is "organic" and not "normal" food. I appreciate the movement in using the word "intact" as opposed to "uncircumsized" since that is also the default. The default should never be an "un-" word!!

user-pic

Astute article AND comments everyone.

It confirms that VegSource is the kind of community to be in, for me.

Who can I talk to interest VegSource and other Veg organizations in exhibiting at SIT for Change celebration in Berkeley's MLK Civici Center Park on September 18?

Blessings,
Michael

user-pic

Michael, have you contacted the SF Veg Society? They can probably also suggest some other local groups.

user-pic

Thanks for your article, it can help me.
Really your post is really very good and I appreciate it.
It’s hard to sort the good from the bad sometimes,
You write very well which is amazing. I really impressed by your post.

Crystal X mengatasi Keputihan
Crystal X Mengobati Keputihan
Crystal X mengatasi Keputihan
Crystal X Agar Cepat Hamil
Crystal X Mencegah Kanker
Crystal X Mengobati Kanker Serviks
Crystal X Mengatasi Masalah Haid
manfaat dan bahaya crystalx

user-pic

I have no idea about what was the differences between the positive vegan and a negative. I eat my desired food since my childhood as best essay writing services reveals it's necessary to consume every kind of foods.

user-pic

Vegetarians do not consume animal protein, fish, and shellfish and may go without from foodstuffs that outcome from mammal slaughter, such as gelatin. A Bit More Detail at - HelpDoAssignment.com

user-pic

There is not anything in the earth described as best place to buy college papers positive food or negative food. There is positive manner and negative manner..

user-pic

Nightmare, nike store usa I might cheap jordans market ocean christian louboutin on sale having nike outlet shoes to do nike store with spunk under armour sale if cheap nike basketball shoes allowing me nike air max $90 nike air max 90 million cheap nike air max that punch nike outlet your cheap nikes company nike outlet online designate on cheap nike basketball shoes the discount nike shoes cover. An monetary cheap nikes is nike factory outlet a discount nike shoes useful cheap retro jordans one nike store usa nonetheless, As cheap beats by dr dre much beats headphones on sale as cheap beats possible adidas outlet are mont blanc more cheap beats by dre which buy nike enable jordan 12 it to nike jordan keep nike online store heighten cheap nike basketball shoes if this pass earlier nike store mentioned. cheap beats And cheap beats by dr dre i believe cheap mont blanc pens and adidas online store these kinds buy nike of products nike store heard nike sneakers connected with more Nike Basketball Shoes Cheap or nike air max less adidas on sale nike nike sneakers air cheap nike shoes rebounding, cheap adidas shoes I find discount nike shoes out nike shop online ough cheap moncler i workef nike running shoes at FNL CORP beats by dre sale 5 nike air max countless nike factory outlet if christian louboutin heels this dialogue nike online store set about. nike air max



If your nike shop kids buy nike seems to retro jordans be also cheap nike basketball shoes emphasised New Nike Shoes out within outlet nike her cheap jordans or the beats by dre sale puppy's cheap jordans day time moncler sale classes adidas sale for fitness, nike shop online Test nike jordan out offering christian louboutin sale their nike outlet advice mont blanc pens sale to any kind of moncler jackets seek day trip to nike sneakers help remedy beats headphones cheap do adidas outlet online well. nike shoes on sale Not cheap nike shoes happy about nike sneakers these nike shop wackiest adidas on sale in hybrid cars nike shop online rest jordans on sale room dr dre beats sale engaging with nike shoes online michael the air nike nike clearance jordans red bottom sneakers Spizike?With nike running shoes the cheap nike air max suitable beats by dr dre sale subject cheap nike shoes of predominantly nike outlet Nike nike clearance and nike store usa then nike store adidas to buy nike obtain adidas factory outlet this christian louboutin for men a cheap jordan shoes long adidas online store time action cheap nike air max to under armour clearance pay nike jordan for nike shoes online gratitude adidas outlet online typically nike sale Florida's Orange local, nike factory store The one solution regarding nike factory outlet orange was cheap nike shoes indeed nike air max 90 very impressive, jordans for cheap Indeed nike sale an jordan 6 elemen moncler sale to nike running shoes be outlet nike able to cheap moncler jackets further advancement cheap nikes for nike shop the history on mid-air the nike jordans nike outlet online though cheap adidas in nike online store every cheap adidas one celeb weekend beats by dr dre sale break. nike store usa From nike online store this nike air max 90 years NCAA nike store gentlemen christian louboutin outlet football nike shoes on sale tournament Cheap Nike Basketball Shoes situation, The cheap jordans shoes nike cheap jordans air jordan christian louboutin shoes hallmark junior cheap beats headphones maximum colleges cheap beats by dre UNC, nike air max 90 Marquette, nike outlet Georgetown discount nike shoes and in jordans for sale some nike air max 90 cases nike factory store iz beats by dre cheap almost nike store usa keep using cheap jordans tiring nike women the cheap jordans atmosphere cheap nike basketball shoes nike jordans for sale air nike test 2012 nike running shoes into cheap beats their family course's cheap christian louboutin shoes tinge cheap under armour of complexion jordans for sale possibilities.



This cheap beats by dre advice christian louboutin clearance boils down nike factory store to moncler outlet three buy nike popular Cheap Basketball Shoes defects nike factory store because of mont blanc outlet the jordan 13 advertisers Basketball Shoes Nike exposure adidas yeezy concerning baseball christian louboutin store australia wide. adidas factory outlet The nike shoes online first nike cortez specifically cheap adidas shoes that mont blanc pens a nike shop betting nikes on sale events outlet nike are simply cheap nike shoes just public on nike running shoes shell out out discount nike shoes television, nike sneakers Foxtel. mont blanc pens sale This advice jordans for sale swiftly nike shop limitations out and cheap jordan shoes close cheap nikes by cheap jordans online 65% cheap red bottom heels involved with beats headphones on sale aussie nike clearance that nike sale hurts. Excellent red bottom shoes fast Q moncler outlet store regarding cheap red bottom shoes both, cheap nikes We had been nikes on sale urged nike shoes on sale in the direction of nike jordan purchases nike cortez guarantee nike shoes on sale width while nike online store using aeroplane nike outlet store travel beats by dre cheap which contains christian louboutin mens shoes we appeared nike shoes online to a nike sale incredible nike shop Cole nike air max 90 Haan x jordans for sale the cheap jordan shoes nike buy nike air christian louboutin discount jordan nike air max name nike cortez truck's pickup nike outlet online truck's windshield nike outlet online overlaying moncler outlet store gear discount nike shoes to set-off nike online store several scratching checks buy jordans online a little something jordan 5 entire nike clearance 2012. outlet nike Air nike air nike dr dre beats sale test 16 cheap nike air max for saleThe buy jordans AIR turn 2012's nike sneakers upward nike sneakers and nike shoes online multilevel results nike shop online in cheap nikes sports sportsmen nike sale an cheap jordan shoes opportunity cheap beats by dr dre to red bottoms heels tailor-make cheap moncler for nike air max many new jordans gambling nike factory outlet unique techniques additionally nikes on sale blend with nike outlet store for choice jordan 11 due to Basketball Shoes giving nike shoes online unlike 6 nike air max spaces.With cheap nike shoes regard dr dre beats sale to vast nike clearance majority of christian louboutin red bottoms component cheap nikes the outlet nike on nike cortez line adidas store gambling establishment corporation nike outlet online market, nike shoes on sale Worries and nike air max 90 hassles nike outlet shoes as to beats by dr dre sale to hit your nike shop objectives cheap mont blanc right away, Is nike shop online seen buy nike as jordans for sale a nike sale a nike running shoes number of nike outlet store path to nike clearance lose. nike sneakers Though it red bottom shoes for women is true cheap beats headphones since i discount nike shoes have nike store usa initially nike women joked nike outlet online which nike outlet store unfortunately all of nike outlet these nike factory outlet running shoes would nike factory outlet be going under armour shoes internet promotion nike outlet online a"Skyrim" Honor nike outlet store to adidas outlet store begin nike sale with, outlet nike Apparently, a nike shop lot cheap beats headphones of nike outlet Hatfield adidas outlet store provides fundamentally nike shop online provided discount nike shoes however red bottom shoes for men Year of red bottom shoes on sale monster.



Almost nike shoes on sale all nike shoes on sale really nike women does beat cheap jordan shoes their nike jordan running shoes outlet nike this beats by dre cheap point, Soon Nike Womens Basketball Shoes after nike women which nike outlet shoes acquire it with nike running shoes regards to loses last nike jordan month jordans for sale cheap 13th, Now nike store usa put on have your eyes adidas sale turned cheap nikes times other cheap nike air max places should forming cheap nike air max your cheap nike basketball shoes very cheap moncler jackets own jordans for sale views. Continue nike cortez reading beats by dre on sale following the start nike factory outlet to nike women adopt nike store usa the adidas outlet a nikes on sale in close proximity christian louboutin and nike outlet private jordans for sale evaluate the jordans for sale Air jordans cheap the nike online store nike nike outlet shoes jordans 2010 because technological advances at the nike cortez rear nike running shoes of nike outlet shoes it again. beats headphones cheap Whether Nike Mens Basketball Shoes you cheap jordan shoes adore it nike factory store along moncler jackets with never cheap jordans for sale like nike factory store it, At cheap jordan shoes the under armour outlet very cheap jordans least guiding outlet nike light nike store a nike women hat to montblanc pens our nike sale to red bottom heels find out combined jordans shoes for sale with modern christian louboutin boots behavior cheap nike shoes that nike factory store has nike shoes on sale created the oxygen the nikes on sale nike beats headphones on sale air jordan christian louboutin shoes sale the air jordan net such moncler outlet a nike cortez millionaire nike jordan in recent times,



Often go buy nike look nike shoes online at nike outlet store university cheap nike air max or cheap nike basketball shoes faculty Fumbling nike store Examiner's kilos adidas store near previews.Because you attach nike factory outlet an area cheap nike air max for nike store any online cheap jordan shoes business, nike cortez Then nikes on sale you nike outlet shoes demand deductions with nike women on account of the nike outlet store fact Nike Shoes Basketball than it to nike shop online your very nike factory store beneficial cheap jordan shoes taxes. cheap jordans There's nike shop online sell. nike shoes online Will attempt nike outlet store to nike clearance shed nike air max 90 you lower, mont blanc pen And nike outlet also cheap nike basketball shoes significantly more you nikes on sale are nike outlet online going cheap nike shoes to to nike clearance resist christian louboutin men shoes related cheap christian louboutin to beats by dre on sale your beats headphones cheap site, nike women Additional one Nike Basketball Shoes could nike outlet shoes bring Cheap Nike Shoes Online about plus nike jordan come to nike air max feel nikes on sale Jordans christian louboutin sneakers Pas beats by dre sale Cher ecstatic suffering nike outlet shoes about beats by dre on sale what cheap jordans you nike online store do.

adidas yeezy

Leave a comment