Lifestyle

 

J Morris Hicks

J Morris Hicks

Posted February 26, 2011

Published in Health, Lifestyle

  • digg
  • Delicious
  • Furl
  • reddit
  • blinklist
  • Technorati
  • stumbleupon

Why do some vegetarians get fat?

Read More: obesity, vegan, vegetarian

Get VegSource Alerts Get VegSource Alerts

First Name

Email

Email This Story to a Friend




The "V" words and why I don't like them

 Thumbnail image for Photo Newport.jpgVegetarian and Vegan. Those words are all about what they don't eat. For example; they don't eat meat, they don't eat cheese, they don't eat eggs, etc. So if they're not eating animal products, why are so many of them overweight? It's because many are obsessed about what they don't eat and don't give nearly enough thought to what they are eating. This gives you one clue as to why I don't like the "V" words.

While I probably eat more whole plants than any man in Connecticut, I don't describe myself as a vegetarian or vegan. If you want a label that describes the way I eat, then I would go with a "human who prefers to eat the natural diet for our species."

 

As for labels, it seems to me that the people who need the "label" are the folks that have decided to eat the toxic western diet, which is nowhere close to the natural diet for humans. When people ask me if I am a vegetarian, I am tempted to say, "No, I am an American." So, to summarize, here are...

My top five reasons why I don't like the "V" words

  1. They're really more about conveying information about what a person doesn'teat...when what a person does eat is far more important.
  2. There is no commonly understood definition for either vegetarian or vegan; you ask the first ten people you see in your office this morning and you may get ten definitions.
  3. Many vegetarians and vegans are not necessarily eating a very healthy diet. Too much refined carbohydrates, too much cheese, too much eggs, too much oil, too many potato chips and not nearly enough whole plants.
  4. As I pride myself on eating a near optimal diet; deriving over 80% of my calories from whole plant foods; I don't like to be grouped in the large number of so-called vegetarians who don't eat a very healthy diet.
  5. Bottom Line. I simply don't like labels and stereotypes and the prejudices and misunderstandings that go along with them...and 90% of the western world still think that the "V" people are a little weird.

Thumbnail image for A Texas 4Leaf meal.jpgFortunately for me and my family, I discovered the world-changing power of consuming mostly plants - in nature's package in 2003 and we have benefited greatly from that knowledge -- even if I have an occasional bite of fish or cheese.

The meal at left is a good example of ordering a healthy meal in Texas -- even during Rodeo Week....Monday in Galveston. Except for a little oil used in cooking and the processed beer in the Lone Star, 100% of the calories in this meal were derived from whole plants...lots of veggies, new potatoes and brown rice. If more vegetarians ate like this at every meal, there would be far fewer of them with a weight problem.

Many of our medical experts have confirmed that a guy like myself that eats an enormous amount of whole plants with a rare bite of cheese or fish is likely to be much healthier than the self-described vegan who NEVER eats any animal products but, instead of eating lots of whole plants, gets most of her calories from oil, sugar, and highly processed foods...and that is exactly why many vegetarians AND vegans are overweight or obese. 

After all, they could eat nothing but potato chips and Diet Coke and call themselves vegan...but they wouldn't be very healthy...nor would they be at their ideal weight.

For more discussion about the optimal diet for humans, you might enjoy our recent blog about "where Bill Clinton is getting his protein these days." From the Hobby Airport in Houston – Be well and have a great day…

—J. Morris Hicks…blogging daily at hpjmh.com


FACEBOOK COMMENTS:


1 Comment | Leave a comment

user-pic

Well, I already had a scrap with Jeff Novick about this on Facebook, regarding a similar quote from Dr Campbell (both of whom I admire greatly!)

Look at the name of the website publishing your rant against the vegetarian label.

"VegSource - your source for all things vegetarian."

Distancing yourself because _some_ veg*ns have more strict moral awareness than health awareness is divisive and unhelpful. Veg*ns usually have more than one reason for their lifestyle choice, and you can see that variety on this site. It is only your opinion which reason is "more important" than any other.

Instead of alienating veg*ns (a visible population segment unlike you "healthy plantatarians"), why not embrace them with the health message?

And as for why so many vegetarians gain weight, you might find food for thought in my post Veg*ism and Eating Disorders

If you like, veg

Leave a comment