Sexism
is a Sin: The Biblical Basis for Female Equality
by J.R. Hyland
Sarasota, Florida, Viatoris Pubs., 1995, 146 pp.
Reviewed by
Stephen Kaufman, M.D.
Those
who believe that all the egalitarian movements are inter-related
will appreciate this provocative interpretation of Judeo-Christian
writings. J.R. Hyland, a Christian minister, first looks at the
two, quite different, creation stories of Genesis 1 and 2. Hyland
argues that the stories describe two different events. The first
human creation, which she calls Homo perfectus, was truly created
in God's image. This being reflected Elohim, an androgenous God
who unites what Hyland terms the "male and female principles" and
who gives these God-like humans "dominion" over all creation. These
humans, like inhabitants of Eden, ate no flesh (Gen 1:29).
The Bible does not describe the fate of Homo perfectus, but it
does detail the stories of the second human creation, which Hyland
recognizes as Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens, which started with Adam
and Eve, was never created in God's image, and these imperfect humans
were limited to the role of gardeners in Eden. God gave animals
to Adam as companions, never as raw materials for exploitation.
Translators have often indicated that Eve was formed from one of
Adam's ribs. Hyland shows that the Hebrew words describing this
event actually indicate that Eve emerged from Adam's entire personhood,
reflecting how man and woman are intimately related to each other
and how each represents part of a whole. Interestingly, Hyland notes
that translating from Hebrew, the Fall represented Adam and Eve's
choice to experience evil by partaking of the fruit. This added
a divisive element to their previously blissful lives, and destroyed
their own androgenous, male/female identity. No longer automatically
able to see both male and female attributes within themselves, humans
could now only obtain self-knowledge by interacting with and learning
from members of the (now) opposite sex.
Hyland demonstrates how a major theme throughout Scriptures involves
God's attempts to encourage humans to manifest their true, androgenous
reality while humans, in their fallen state, repeatedly deny this
reality and lead lives of violence and destruction. By failing to
unite the "male principle"--action and overcoming--with the "female
principle"--caregiving and concern-- humans lead lives of suffering
and strife between communities and within their own communities.
Action and overcoming untempered by the female principle of compassion
is violence. Meanwhile, caregiving and concern without activism
outside the immediate household is irrelevant to building a compassionate
and just society. Raising boys in an environment of love and then
delivering the boys to a culture that expects them to be warriors
fails to achieve peace. And, raising girls to become mothers who
accept their role of raising future soldiers continues the cycle
of violence.
The Hebrew Scriptures describe brutal wars that must have made
the Hebrews one of the most feared tribes of the ancient world.
Nevertheless, scattered throughout the Hebrew writings, particularly
Genesis and the latter prophets such as Amos, Jeremiah, and Isaiah,
are guideposts for peace that Jesus, a Jew, recognized as the best
hope for human salvation. Jesus perfectly united the male and female
principles. He was compassionate and caring, yet he recognized that
encouraging others to show mercy was just as important as his own
acts of kindness. Jesus' teachings, such as the Sermon on the Mount,
make clear his belief that all people can and should follow his
example, reflecting the view that all people may manifest the male
and female principles.
Unfortunately, Hyland notes, that part of Jesus' ministry which
embraced the "female principle" was later neglected by attributing
caring and nurturing to Mary, who has been venerated as his loving
mother (the traditional, limited role of women). This has allowed
militarists to regard Jesus as "all male," making room for the Crusades
and other holy wars that stain Christianity's history.
Jesus' message has not been lost on everyone, however. Ann Lee,
who founded the Millennial Church (later known as the Shaker Church)
believed Jesus valued women as equals, and her religious community
reflected her feminist ideals. The Shakers met considerable, often
violent resistance, and the women's movement continues to struggle
against sexist ideologies and practices.
Hyland asserts that the Scriptures offer a brilliant insight into
human affairs, an insight that religious leaders and their political
allies have generally ignored or suppressed. It is critical that
men recognize and nurture their own female elements, and women their
male elements. Without this, there can be no peace, not with nature,
not with neighboring communities, and not within our own communities.
Stephen R. Kaufman, M.D.
|